Document metadata
type: workshop-module
status: open
module: EG-04
title: Assign the evidence chain
gate: Who discovers, authenticates, connects, presents, and acts on each decisive part of Samuel's history?
prerequisites: EG-02, EG-03
EG-04: Assign the evidence chain
Purpose
Give every major force an indispensable evidentiary function and prevent the climax from collapsing into one character explaining everything.
Established
The Resistance reconstructs evidence Samuel kept partitioned across records, systems, bloodlines, witnesses, and infrastructure. Sylvan may present or act on the verified result without owning the Resistance or its discoveries. Konrad's inner circle recognizes Samuel's repeated method. Legitimate institutions retain formal outcome and processing authority.
The present attack supplies a live comparison. Sylvan and the Luminai can preserve Samuel's attempt to assign him a role, Konrad and Aiden's response, and Samuel's revisions after Sylvan refuses. The Resistance must own the historical connection showing that this sequence matches postwar false autonomy, reactivation, captured initiatives, and the recruitment of other leaders.
The evidentiary burden is narrower than a judgment about religion. Samuel did not author the existing prophecy. The chain must show that he selected Sylvan as its supposed enemy and manufactured the actionable confirmations: access logs, revisions, timing, intermediaries, permissions, source records, or repeated language across otherwise separate groups. A failed prophecy by itself proves too little.
Sources: 02 Story/Groups/The Resistance, 07 QA/2026-09-17 - Resistance and Revelation Reassessment, 07 Coordination/Prose Development/01 - Converging Revelation.
Four possibilities
- Distributed convergence: each force holds one fragment that becomes actionable only when compared.
- Resistance spine: the Resistance owns the chronology while specialist institutions authenticate distinct record classes.
- Live-method proof: current behavior supplies the pattern that allows older records to be attributed correctly.
- Adversarial audit: Samuel challenges provenance in stages, and each failed challenge reveals another independent source.
Central author gate
Which indispensable record lets the Resistance connect Samuel's live identification of Sylvan to Konrad and Aiden's postwar reactivation, who authenticates each evidence class, and what final connection changes the meaning of at least three earlier facts?
Scene test
Every evidentiary handoff changes what someone can safely do next.
Adversarial test
If Sylvan can discover, verify, interpret, and present everything alone, the Resistance and affected groups lose agency. If no institution can authenticate the chain, the outcome depends on belief rather than proof.